Penn Yan

Over the recent months roughly 24 homes have been sold with an average sold price of $251,248. That is a decrease of $93,025 from the previous period.

--

Main Type Of Housing: Penn Yan offers residents a dense suburban feel, surrounded by rural communities. Located in Yates County, the Village of Penn Yan is primarily in the Town of Milo, but a small section is in the Town of Benton.

Known For: Penn Yan is a charming historic village at the north end of the east branch of Keuka Lake with amazing restaurants and bars and lots of outdoor activities. Because of the shallow waters, Keuka is one of the warmer Finger Lakes. It is unusual because it is Y-shaped, in contrast to the long and narrow shape of the other Finger Lakes. The land surrounding the lake is mostly comprised of vineyards and other agriculture, which provide a beautiful backdrop to a day of swimming, fishing, or boating. Penn Yan is also home to the oldest operating flour mill in the country, The Birkett Mills, located in the heart of the Village along the Keuka Lake Outlet.

Attractions We Love: Keuka Lake Wine Trail, Keuka Lake Outlet Trail, Apple Barrel Orchards, Finger Lakes Rail Riders, Lakeside Country Club (semi-private), Morgan Marine, Keuka Lake State Park, Seneca Mill & Falls, Spotted Duck Creamery

Major Retailers: Tops Friendly Markets, CVS, ACE Hardware, Dollar General, Tractor Supply Co. Penn Yan is home to many thriving small local retailers as well.

Penn Yan offers a charming small-town atmosphere in the heart of the Finger Lakes region, with a real estate market featuring historic homes, waterfront properties, and modern developments. The area attracts families, retirees, and vacation homeowners with its scenic lake views, thriving local businesses, and access to wineries and outdoor recreation. Homebuyers appreciate the affordability compared to larger cities while still enjoying a vibrant downtown, cultural events, and seasonal activities. Whether seeking a year-round residence or a lakeside retreat, Penn Yan real estate blends rural charm with modern conveniences.